SALVADR.MIS (Converted)
American Consulate, Hermosillo
April 28, 1987
Editor
Newsweek
New York City
Sir:
Robert Rivard, whom you say "lived and worked in Central America", doesn't display
much knowledge of either contemporary or past Salvadoran events if he is to be judged
by what he has to say about Mormon missionaries in the area ("In Search of Change",
p. 40, Newsweek
, April 27, 1987). Rivard talks about a Mormon missionary addressing "the few peasants
who remained in the town . . . in English
(emphasis added) under a hot dry-season sun . . . (about) God vs. Communism (and
his) importance back home."
The President of the Mormon Mission in Salvador is a Salvador-born Latter-day Saint
who is a close personal friend of mine. While he speaks fluent English in addition
to his native Spanish, he would never resort to speaking English to his fellow countrymen. More than eighty per cent of his missionaries in Salvador are native-born Latin
Americans, most from adjoining Central American countries, most of the rest from
Mexico or South America. And the few non-Latin North Americans among the missionary
contingent are fluent in Spanish and would never be insensitive (or stupid) enough to speak
English to a group of natives. This is something reserved for Gringo tourists and
Gringo newsmen.
Nor is it credible that any Mormon missionary, even the few North American youths
serving missions in Salvador (or any other country to which they were assigned) would
be crude enough, or foolish enough, to brag about "their importance back home" (how
important could a nineteen year old undergraduate be in any event?)
Communism, pro
or con
is not part of the missionary teaching program. And without a great deal more circumstantial
evidence I have a hard time believing that any Latter-day Saint missionary in Salvador
or elsewhere would be wasting his time either preaching politics or speaking to an uninterested group of local women under the scorching sun when instructions
are to preach only the Restored Gospel of Jesus Christ in its fullness, and only
to the interested in their own homes by prior appointment. The Mormon Church wouldn't
be the fastest growing church in the world -- above all in Latin America, if its missionaries
spent their time as bootlessly as Rivard reports.
And I think I know what I'm talking about. I know Central America, too. Probably
better than Rivard. Before my retirement after twenty-eight years in the Foreign
Service I served as Charge
d'Affaires ad interim
at the U.S. Embassy in Guatemala and have enough experience with biased media reporters
to wonder about Rivard's entire article. Apart from my work at the Embassy, I was
also Counselor in the Guatemalan LDS Church Stake (diocese) Presidency. And I am
currently Counselor to the local Mormon Bishop here in Hermosillo, Mexico. So I know
something of Church affairs and practices. And what Rivard says about North American
LDS missionary braggarts in the midday sun bears so little resemblance to what I
know of Mormon missionaries that I have reason to doubt other elements of his story.
I've sometimes though the U.S. press automatically rejects anything said to them by
American embassy personnel, accepting as ultimate truth whatever contrary they can
dig up from whatever alternative source. Reporters are is a business at least as
competitive as any other and just as prone to corner cutting as any other profession. I
have seen reporters slant facts and alter circumstances to pep up a story in an otherwise
boring week just to make their byline. I, for one, wasn't at all surprised at the
Washington Post
/Janet Cook brouhaha a few years ago.
I'm not trying to bash freedom of the press. Indeed, I agree with fellow Mormon Jack
Anderson that the only truly effective means of disciplining the press is the freedom
of competing reporters to catch out the mistakes of their colleagues. I just wish
there were a bit more of this peer-discipline. There seems to be an auto-immunity
of reporters to criticism, just as there is of doctors and lawyers to peer sanction.
In the meantime, I believe it is the duty of those who know the facts to write letters
to the editor such as this to set the record straight when one reads such downright
inaccurate reporting as that of Robert Rivard when he takes to task the Church I
know best just to add "color" to his story that things aren't going just as well
as he'd like in Salvador. Mormons have enough real problems like Mark Hoffman and Sonia Johnson
without the press faking it up just for the fun of it.
Sincerely,
|